Non-VT virtualization tools

Registered by Dustin Kirkland  on 2009-11-07

KVM is clearly the best choice on Ubuntu for Virtualization. But this requires CPU support for Virtualization Technology (VT).

We have been operating for 2+ years on the premise that VT would be ubiquitous in the near future, enabling full virtualization everywhere.

I believe that this premise has proven false. While much (though not all) server hardware has VT, VT is a premium feature on much laptop, desktop, consumer-grade hardware.

In particular, hardware shipping from the major vendors with Ubuntu preloaded is often netbook, or low-cost hardware options that rarely have VT.

I suggest that we should reconsider our options for providing some form of supported virtualization for hardware without VT.

The options:
 * qemu
  * basic emulation, no acceleration at all, very slow
 * kqemu
  * as of Karmic, this is no longer an option; upstream qemu-kvm disables kqemu support because it breaks kvm
  * as of Lucid, the qemu-0.12 version we're planning carry will not have the kqemu code in the tree at all
 * xen
  * still requires massive patch for dom0, very difficult to support
 * virtualbox
  * extremely popular in the community
  * nice gui
  * slow compared to kvm
  * fast compared to qemu

Blueprint information

Status:
Complete
Approver:
Jos Boumans
Priority:
Medium
Drafter:
Dustin Kirkland 
Direction:
Needs approval
Assignee:
Scott Moser
Definition:
Obsolete
Series goal:
Accepted for lucid
Implementation:
Deferred
Milestone target:
milestone icon ubuntu-10.04-beta-2
Completed by
Scott Moser on 2013-05-13

Related branches

Sprints

Whiteboard

jib review 2009-12-18: Updating documentation for items that went away seems crucial. However, our support for virtualbox should probably be a desktop project if anything. I've changed the work items to reflect this. Is there anyone in the desktop team that has an opinion on virtualbox adaptation?

Secondary engineer: kirkland

Status:
(not updated yet)

Work items:
[kirkland] announce why kqemu "went away" in Ubuntu: DONE
[smoser] scrub wiki/help/server-guide documentation for "kqemu": DONE

Possible desktop work items:
 * update documentation for virtualbox, lxc: TODO
 * full bug triage against virtualbox-ose: TODO

(?)

Work Items