Create a space for collaborative editing of card databases, e.g. a wiki

Registered by glotz on 2009-08-04

There are many nice sets of cards available but they could be made even better by collaborative editing, just like wikipedia. Also for bonus points, it would be nice if this space was accessible from the program itself.

Blueprint information

Status:
Not started
Approver:
None
Priority:
Low
Drafter:
None
Direction:
Needs approval
Assignee:
None
Definition:
New
Series goal:
None
Implementation:
Unknown
Milestone target:
None

Related branches

Sprints

Whiteboard

We are migrating the feature requests from here to https://mnemosyne.uservoice.com/ . Please submit your request there.

There is a similar feature being implemented in Anki presently (05/11/12) (http://ankiweb.net/deck/subscriptions). The main thing is that there should be one key field like in a database which is a unique field that has no equivalent.

The question field would not be adequate despite the fact that it is unique or can be made to be unique because it is a commonly edited field. I.e. the problem is that one user would be able to edit a field and there would be no way to let the program know which card to update in those subscribers that did not allow edits.

If you have a wiki format to permit edits I suggest a voting system that allows people to vote on votes or vote on voters not just vote on the quality of a particular edit/addition. There should be thresholds on the minimum number of vote strength to allow an edit to persist and a maximum amount of time to allow consideration of the change/addition.

A system with one "mentor" to decide which edits to allow and subscribers to that mentor would be simpler to implement and more realistic ATM IMHO. Since Mnemosyne uses XML and other open technologies this could be implemented by a clever Web designer with knowledge of SQL and perhaps would have nothing directly to do with Mnemosyne. That is the nature of open source after all: liberty of collaboration.

Before this is implemented or at the same time the site - if it is through a site - should give advice on ideal card qualities and study habits, much like an FAQ. This FAQ is really important! This site should also allow different card file format conversions.

(?)

Work Items

This blueprint contains Public information 
Everyone can see this information.